President Donald Trump has vowed to abolish the Common Core standards in English language arts and math. We thought this would be time to explain what the Common Core standards are, and whether the federal government can in fact abolish them.
Q. What are the Common Core standards?
A. Common Core standards explain what students should know and be able to do by the end of each grade level, from kindergarten through 12th grade. This is different from a curriculum, which tells educators how to teach the standards. Each district and school has the flexibility to choose its own curriculum in order to meet the goals of the standards. However, the state has adopted lists of recommended curriculum materials for grades K-8 in math and English language arts and has adopted “frameworks” – which are like blueprints – that explain how to teach them.
Q. What did the Common Core standards replace?
A. Common Core standards in math and English language arts replaced California’s previous state standards, on which students were assessed using the former STAR tests. The new standards are considered more rigorous and require students to think critically and solve problems, so they can be prepared for college and 21st century careers. They are assessed with computer-based Smarter Balanced tests in grades 3-8 and 11.
Q. Can the federal government get rid of the Common Core?
A. No. They are state standards. As president, Trump will not have the authority to abolish the Common Core standards. Although Trump has attacked the standards, the new Every Student Succeeds Act specifically prohibits the federal government from exercising any control over a state, district or school’s “instructional content, academic standards and assessments, curricula, or program of instruction….”
Q. What does federal law require in terms of standards?
A. Although Common Core standards are not federally mandated, states were encouraged to adopt them by the U. S. Department of Education under the No Child Left Behind law. Under the new Every Student Succeeds Act, known as ESSA, states are required to adopt rigorous standards, but they can decide what they are. States must also test students on them, but the old focus solely on test scores to rank or punish schools are gone and replaced by new accountability systems that look at other factors, including access to college prep courses, suspension and expulsion rates, graduation rates and the school’s climate – or how students and parents feel about the school.
Q. How were the standards developed?
A. Common Core standards were created by education experts led by a coalition of governors, state education department officials, child advocates and business leaders who wanted students to graduate ready to go to college without needing remedial classes and able to fill high-tech jobs now filled by workers from other countries. They also wanted “common” standards at each grade level, so that students who move from one state to another could have the same foundation of knowledge and skills no matter where they live.
Q. What’s different about English language arts standards?
A. One of the big changes in the English language arts standards is that students are required to read more nonfiction texts and to analyze and compare them. Students must be able to state a position and back it up with specifics. The new standards also stress literacy across all subject-areas, emphasizing reading, writing and speaking. And because California has so many English learners, this state has added English Language Development standards that require teachers of every subject to stress academic vocabulary so English learners will become fluent more quickly.
Q. What’s different about the math standards?
A. The math standards include mathematical practices, which are tools and skills students use to solve problems, such as perseverance. They also include content standards such as addition, subtraction, multiplication and algebra. The mathematical practices are the same at every grade level, but they build on each other. One of these is to persevere, even if the problem is so challenging that a student might be tempted to just give up. The new standards emphasize the idea that struggle is productive and that there can be many ways to solve a problem.
Q. How are districts adapting to the new standards?
A. Some of the positive things I’ve seen come out of the Common Core include project-based learning, interdisciplinary lessons, and more collaboration among teachers and students. Project-based learning is more hands-on than traditional instruction and gets kids excited about lessons, which could include experiments or real-world scenarios. Interdisciplinary lessons include more than one subject, but are focused on a theme. For example, a class could research global warming by doing science experiments, mathematical calculations, and group reports and presentations. This is intended to make the lessons more relevant to students so they will care more about what they are learning and see connections between their class work and the real world.
But one area where there are differences among districts is how much training teachers and administrators have received. In some districts, there is still a lot of training needed to fully implement the new standards.
What else would you like to know about the Common Core? Let us know at firstname.lastname@example.org
To get more reports like this one, click here to sign up for EdSource’s no-cost daily email on latest developments in education.
We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.
Christy l walker 4 years ago4 years ago
I am a mother of 5. This is absolute garbage. This is not preparing our children for their future. If anything it’s making them basket cases. I don’t remember having stress over math and reading a book as a kid! I spoke with a doctor who told me he sees a child everyday for anxiety! Stop destroying our children!
MarieP 5 years ago5 years ago
It is common knowledge, the two main professors for Math and English refused to approve the common core curriculum, that does not prepare students for 4 year college.
ANITA JOHNSTON 6 years ago6 years ago
Who were the participants in developing the math portion of the Common Core standards and what are their qualifications?
Theresa Harrington 6 years ago6 years ago
Here is the information provided on the Common Core website: http://www.corestandards.org/about-the-standards/development-process/
And here is an EdSource Q & A with Jason Zimba, one of the authors, which also links to an NPR profile of him: https://edsource.org/2015/common-core-standards-emphasize-math-that-matters-most/75556
Henry K. 6 years ago6 years ago
Common Core is nothing more than another well-intentioned trend designed by “experts.” These experts have zero accountability should Common Core, similar to all the previous trends, fail to generate positive results. The problem is that over-focusing on problem-solving skills creates specialists, and that is not what businesses will need. The future growth will be in AI, robotics, general tech (including software), and biotech. These employees will need to be able to adapt quickly and be … Read More
Common Core is nothing more than another well-intentioned trend designed by “experts.” These experts have zero accountability should Common Core, similar to all the previous trends, fail to generate positive results. The problem is that over-focusing on problem-solving skills creates specialists, and that is not what businesses will need. The future growth will be in AI, robotics, general tech (including software), and biotech. These employees will need to be able to adapt quickly and be able to cross professional domain boundaries as jobs are created and destroyed. These employees must have skills the California schools do not teach, which include social and emotional skills (difficult when kids are staring at their smartphones all day long), teamwork, the ability to work across cultures, etc. The best tech jobs go to the best and the brightest, yet public school teachers on average have lower SAT scores than the average graduating students. Do you see the disconnect?
Ann Thomas 6 years ago6 years ago
Why does President Trump dislike Common Core so much?
Tony 6 years ago6 years ago
Could this be a hindrance for children with a language barrier and limited schooling in the United States,
i.e. children of immigrants, etc?
lorie 6 years ago6 years ago
Not a comment but a question! I have an 8th grader who has been in private school and thus, not exposed to Common Core whatsoever. He will be attending a public California high school in 9th grade. Since he has had zero common core, how much might this impact him moving forward in math and English? Especially math as he is taking Algebra 1 presently and will be going into the … Read More
Not a comment but a question! I have an 8th grader who has been in private school and thus, not exposed to Common Core whatsoever. He will be attending a public California high school in 9th grade. Since he has had zero common core, how much might this impact him moving forward in math and English? Especially math as he is taking Algebra 1 presently and will be going into the standard Common Core track for freshmen. Am I setting him up for failure by moving him? Any help and input is much appreciated! Thank you in advance!
Theresa Harrington 6 years ago6 years ago
Actually, the Common Core standards delay algebra I until ninth grade, so your son should have a good foundation going in, as long as he understands the concepts behind algebra, and hasn't just been memorizing formulas. In English, he will be required to use evidence to support his arguments, which is also common in Advanced Placement courses. If the school he attended included a rigorous curriculum, he should be able to do well. He may … Read More
Actually, the Common Core standards delay algebra I until ninth grade, so your son should have a good foundation going in, as long as he understands the concepts behind algebra, and hasn’t just been memorizing formulas. In English, he will be required to use evidence to support his arguments, which is also common in Advanced Placement courses. If the school he attended included a rigorous curriculum, he should be able to do well. He may even be able to go into geometry as a freshmen, if he gets a good grade in algebra and has a teacher recommendation. You can find out more about what to expect in ninth grade English at: http://www.corestandards.org/ELA-Literacy/RL/9-10/. Here are the math standards, which allow schools to choose the standard algebra I, geometry, algebra II sequence or to select a more integrated approach: http://www.corestandards.org/Math/.