Credit: FangXiaNuo / iStock
The article was updated Aug. 17 to include California-specific data. See inset "Where Californians disagree."

The public’s support for charter schools fell significantly from a year ago nationwide and among both Democrats and Republicans, according to an annual poll by the magazine Education Next. 

Although a small plurality still favor charters, the 12 percentage point drop in support, from 51 percent to 39 percent, marked the biggest shift in this year’s survey results, released Monday (see full results with survey questions).

In its 11th annual poll, Education Next, a research and opinion magazine published by the conservative-leaning Hoover Institution at Stanford University, surveyed 4,214 adults over 18. That was a large enough sample to explore views on some topics in-depth by asking variations of questions to half of respondents. The latest survey was taken in May and June.

The Trump effect: The poll found that President Donald Trump is having a polarizing impact, with more Republicans agreeing with him and more Democrats disagreeing with him on some key education issues. When half of the respondents were told the president’s positions, between 7 and 14 percent more Democrats disagreed with Trump, depending on the issue, while roughly the same percentage of additional Republicans aligned their views with his. Merit pay for teachers and tax credits for private schools were two of the issues; Trump favors both.

By contrast, in his first year in office, in 2008, President Barack Obama a had persuasive, not divisive, impact, with between 11 and 13 percent of Democrats and Republicans indicating agreement with the president’s views on education issues such as charter schools, after Education Next informed them of his positions. By 2010, after 18 months in office, however, the results became more partisan, after Republicans and Democrats were told of Obama’s views.

Common Core’s bad brand:  The survey also found the public has a more nuanced perspective on the Common Core State Standards, which California and most states adopted in 2010. Perception of the once popular standards has slipped sharply, particularly in Republican-led states, but the “escalating trend of opinion against Common Core may have run its course,” Ed Next’s report on the poll said. Forty-one percent supported the standards, the same as last year. That was down from 65 percent in 2013 in the Ed Next poll. Among Republicans, 32 percent supported the Common Core, with 51 percent opposing, compared with 49 percent of Democrats in favor and 28 percent opposed. But when the name “Common Core” isn’t mentioned, 61 percent said they favored the general concept of “standards that are the same across the states” — a primary goal of creating the Common Core. The difference in support between Republicans and Democrats disappeared when not mentioning Common Core by name; support among Republicans doubled.

The results of independent voters were not broken out. In determining who was a Republican or Democrat, pollsters asked respondents which party they leaned toward. Nearly all chose one party or the other, Education Next said.

As for the 12 percentage point nationwide drop in support for charter schools, Education Next Editor in Chief Martin West did not attribute it to the impact of Trump, who has expressed support for charters. There was a big drop among Republicans, from 60 percent to 47 percent, as well as among Democrats, from 45 percent to 34 percent. Support also fell among minorities, though not by as much: from 46 percent to 37 percent among blacks, and from 44 percent to 39 percent among Hispanics.

Charter supporters still outnumber opponents, however, 39 percent to 36 percent. And 25 percent expressed no position, which could mean they are ambivalent or neutral toward them, said West, who is also an associate professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

Ed Next’s report noted that within the past year, progressive Democratic Senators Bernie Sanders, D-VT, and Elizabeth Warren, D-MA, have been outspoken opponents of charters. Last fall, the NAACP called for a moratorium on charters and reiterated it again in July after a national “listening tour.” In addition, the Massachusetts Teachers Association led a much-publicized campaign against a proposal to expand the number of charters in the state, and the California Teachers Association created a website, “Kids Not Profits,” radio ads and a social media campaign calling for tighter restrictions on charter schools.

The impact of these and other developments on public opinion “seems to have gone well beyond the confines of the Democratic Party,” Ed Next wrote.

Responding to the poll results, California Teachers Association President Eric Heins wrote in an email, “Educators, parents and civil rights and community groups have been talking about the need for accountability and transparency of privately run charter schools for some time because of the waste, fraud and abuse, so the decline in support this poll shows comes as no surprise. Democrats, Republicans and minorities are all less supportive after experiencing and learning of horrifying stories that have negatively impacted students in our communities. This is why California’s educators are demanding to make charters more accountable, transparent, and accessible to all students through legislation.”

In an email, Jed Wallace, president and CEO of the California Charter Schools Association, said the Ed Next results underestimated the support of charter schools in California.

Without a doubt, there is a national spotlight on public school choice and we were not surprised to see some changes in support of charter schools nationally as a result reported in the EdNext poll released today.  However, CCSA’s own public opinion polling has found much higher levels of support for charter public schools in California than EdNext’s poll found at the national level,” he wrote.  “Fifty-one percent of respondents to a February 2017 poll indicated support for charters while only twenty-seven percent were unfavorable and twenty-two percent were undecided.  We believe that this is because the California charter sector is more reflective of the values that the public expects of its public schools as a result of charters operating as non-profits and serving all students including English Language Learners and children with special needs.”

The survey did not find an increase in opposition or drop in support for other forms of school choice, however. Opposition to tax-funded scholarships permitting low-income students to attend private schools — an approach favored by U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos and allowed in 16 states — fell from 29 last year to 24 percent, and 54 percent of respondents said they favored them.

Opposition to universal vouchers, giving all families public dollars for a “wider choice” of attending private schools dropped from 48 to 41 percent, while support increased from 37 percent to 41 percent.

Less support for merit pay

The poll did not break down the results by state or region, although 10 percent of the respondents were from California. Paul Peterson, senior editor of Education Next and a government professor at Harvard, said that the views of Californians were roughly similar to respondents nationwide. But on at least one issue, Californians have made their disagreement clear. Two-thirds of all Ed Next respondents nationwide, and 75 percent of those who had not attended college, favored teaching immigrants and other non-English speakers in English-only classrooms. Last November, 74 percent of California voters passed Proposition 58, repealing English-only instruction and removing restrictions on bilingual education.

On other issues, the survey found:

A decline in support for merit pay. Last year, 55 percent of respondents supported “basing part of the salaries of teachers on how much their students learn.” This year, only 46 percent favored it, with 36 percent opposed. Among teachers, 78 percent opposed merit pay, and only 15 percent favored it this year.

Opposition to mandatory union fees. As with last year, 44 percent of the public opposed requiring teachers to pay fees to the union to represent them, even if they choose not to join a union, while 37 percent supported the requirement. Even among teachers, more also opposed mandatory fees than supported, 47 percent to 44 percent. That could be an ominous signal to unions, including the California Teachers Association, if, as many observers predict, the Supreme Court overturns a previous ruling upholding mandatory union fees.

Value of a college degree: Two-thirds of the public said they would want their child to pursue a four-year university degree, while only 22 percent would choose a two-year associate’s degree, and 11 percent would choose neither. However, there was a 24 percentage point gap between white adults who have a college degree and those who don’t; 80 percent of whites with a degree said they’d want their child to go to a four-year college, compared with 56 percent who don’t have a degree. The numbers didn’t change significantly when they were told the costs of college and the projected benefits, in terms of higher salaries, from a four-year degree.

SHARE ARTICLE

Comments (3)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments Policy

The goal of the comments section on EdSource is to facilitate thoughtful conversation about content published on our website. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.

  1. Marvi 1 month ago1 month ago

    I am curious as to why you concluded Common Core only has a branding problem. I support the general idea of standards across states, but not Common Core standards. The dumbed-down, Whole Language, Constructivist Common Core standards are: not evidence-based, and written by people who chose to ignore over 50 years of research on how children learn. Massachusetts and California already had standards writers could have used as a template. Students in school districts fully … Read More

    I am curious as to why you concluded Common Core only has a branding problem. I support the general idea of standards across states, but not Common Core standards. The dumbed-down, Whole Language, Constructivist Common Core standards are: not evidence-based, and written by people who chose to ignore over 50 years of research on how children learn. Massachusetts and California already had standards writers could have used as a template. Students in school districts fully implementing these standards saw impressive gains in student achievement, especially in low-income high English learner populations. We want quality not rebranding.

  2. CarolineSF 1 month ago1 month ago

    No matter what one thinks of the results of this poll, it's worth noting that most people have no idea what a charter school is -- or they have a vague misconception -- which means this poll and all polls on the subject are meaningless. As a similar example, this is an ongoing issue with polls on Prop. 13. When I was blogging, I interviewed a pollster from a well-known polling firm about that. Most … Read More

    No matter what one thinks of the results of this poll, it’s worth noting that most people have no idea what a charter school is — or they have a vague misconception — which means this poll and all polls on the subject are meaningless.

    As a similar example, this is an ongoing issue with polls on Prop. 13. When I was blogging, I interviewed a pollster from a well-known polling firm about that. Most people have no idea what it is when the pollster asks. The pollster shows them/reads them a brief description, and then asks their opinion on the spot, with presumably seconds to digest the description, no further information, no background and no context. No sensible person would believe that was a valid opinion, and thus no sensible person would believe that poll was credible.

    The same holds true with polls on complex education issues like charter schools (and issues like teacher merit pay and tenure).

    Replies

    • Don 1 month ago1 month ago

      As I recall I’ve read other comments by you, Caroline, in which you say charters are not public schools. So it appears that you, too, don’t understand what a charter school is.