To address the shortfall of tech and science workers in the U.S., employers and educators should broaden their definition of who can excel in those fields — extending it to liberal arts majors and students who get mediocre grades in math and science, according to a new study.
“Some students believe if they get a C in algebra then they can never pursue STEM, that STEM is only for the smartest of the smart,” said Erin White, author of the State of STEM study, which was released last month. “But the reality is, the pace of change in the workplace is so extreme that we don’t even know what the jobs or technology of tomorrow will be. The most important skills in the workplace will be flexibility, critical thinking, communication, the ability to adapt quickly to change. … We need to start thinking differently about the definition of STEM and what a STEM professional is.”
The study was conducted by STEMconnector, a Washington D.C. firm that researches science, math, technology and engineering education and jobs. It was based on data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the National Center for Education Statistics, as well as analysis of other research and interviews with 114 students and representatives from universities, technology companies, nonprofits and foundations.
Danika LeDuc, associate dean of the College of Science and a chemistry professor at California State University East Bay, said she often counsels students to stay in the science field even if they’re struggling academically.
“There’s a misconception that you have to be some kind of genius to be in STEM,” she said. “The reality is, there’s a whole wide range of occupations that require STEM skills. If you really don’t like the subject, that’s one thing, but I do hope students understand life has a lot of opportunities.”
Sometimes, a bad grade is just due to poor study habits, she said. She’s had students earn Fs in her class, learn better ways to study, then re-take the class and earn Bs. She’s also had students struggle with classwork but excel in labs, or visa versa. Or switch from a major to a minor in science and go on to thrive in the STEM workplace or in graduate school.
“I think people don’t realize that failure is a big part of science and engineering. That’s how you learn,” she said. “Sometimes you have to fail to move forward.”
Almost 2.5 million science, math, technology and engineering jobs will go unfilled in the U.S. in 2018, according to data gathered by the Smithsonian Institution’s Science Education Center and cited in the study. While high schools and colleges are scrambling to offer more math and science classes and boost students’ interest in those fields, the demand for STEM workers still outstrips the supply.
The study identified five reasons for the shortfall, which it labeled a “talent gap”:
- Fundamental skills deficit. Not enough students are learning basic workplace skills like simple coding or data analysis, and employers aren’t doing enough to train workers. Also, employers screen out too many qualified applicants by requiring skills that aren’t necessarily needed for the job.
- “Belief gap.” Many students — especially students of color, girls and those who are low-income — don’t think of themselves as future scientists or technology experts because they might have struggled with math or science classes. Likewise, some employers overlook applicants who might have less-than-perfect grades in math and science classes or attended second-tier colleges, even though those job applicants could excel in the workplace.
- Access to college. Due to lack of funding or poor preparation, not enough students are pursuing their studies after high school, gaining the skills they need to be competitive in the workforce. Only 35 percent of adults age 25 or older had bachelor’s degrees or higher in 2017, according to the U.S. Census.
- Technology jobs are not evenly distributed around the country. They tend to be clustered in certain metropolitan hubs, such as the San Francisco Bay Area or Austin, Texas, which means that job applicants in other areas who don’t want to relocate are left out.
- White males are disproportionately represented in science, math and technology fields, which echoes the gap between white students and Latino and African-American students’ math achievement in K-12 schools, according to the Pew Research Center.
The solution, according to the study, is to improve science and math education for all students — especially those who are low-income or students of color — beginning in kindergarten. Science-themed after-school programs and school partnerships with tech companies are a key part of that effort, White said. Microsoft, for example, has donated $150 million in grants, employee time and software to the Boys and Girls Clubs of America to promote technology education for low-income students and students of color.
But employers and educators also need to change their perceptions of who can succeed in the math, science and technology fields, she said. They need to look beyond a student’s major or grade point average when evaluating job applicants, and consider other skills that are valuable in the workplace.
“Really, we’re talking about the future of work,” she said, noting that almost every job includes some level of technological skill, whether it’s operating a forklift, working in human resources or programming computers for Google. And most people learn fundamental tech skills on the job — a trend that’s certain to continue as technology evolves faster than schools can teach it.
Ashley Szofer, senior director of communications at Stem Connector, said that employers need to look at resumes “holistically.”
“Someone might have a C average but they were working 30 hours a week — that shows they have great time management skills,” she said. “Cognitive flexibility, communication skills, the ability to collaborate and work on a team — that’s what will be required to succeed in the jobs of tomorrow.”
To get more reports like this one, click here to sign up for EdSource’s no-cost daily email on latest developments in education.
We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.
Bill 5 years ago5 years ago
I'd have to say the main problem with math skills (and by definition language skills) starts in Elementary School (grades K-5), and students who struggle with math by the time they move to middle school are going to struggle a lot more as math is a foundation subject. I agree with Don's comment that not everyone would need a bachelor's in applied math on a given team, a person who is a skilled technical writer or … Read More
I’d have to say the main problem with math skills (and by definition language skills) starts in Elementary School (grades K-5), and students who struggle with math by the time they move to middle school are going to struggle a lot more as math is a foundation subject.
I agree with Don’s comment that not everyone would need a bachelor’s in applied math on a given team, a person who is a skilled technical writer or graphic illustrator could contribute a great deal.
el 5 years ago5 years ago
It's my experience that sometimes people who struggled with math and science topics as high schoolers, but either through simple time and maturity, or a different teaching style, or just renewed interest in the topic, can find competence and confidence in these topics later in life. It's also often the case that something like computer programming is actually really well suited to a foundation of skills that are developed studying the liberal arts - precision … Read More
It’s my experience that sometimes people who struggled with math and science topics as high schoolers, but either through simple time and maturity, or a different teaching style, or just renewed interest in the topic, can find competence and confidence in these topics later in life. It’s also often the case that something like computer programming is actually really well suited to a foundation of skills that are developed studying the liberal arts – precision with word choice, structured logic, clear directives, and the like.
Possibly the public school lesson that was most seminal for my computer programming skills wasn’t set theory but instead learning to write perfect instructions to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. The second would be the logic puzzles that give you a list of qualities and a chart to work out who has the red dog, who has the white dog, etc. These are not typically thought of as STEM lessons or tasks, but they are foundational.
Bev DeVore-Wedding 5 years ago5 years ago
College and Career Readiness really should read Career and College Readiness as I would prefer my students were prepared to find a career(s) that they are interested in as well as can utilize their strengths and skills. Vocational education, apprenticeships, and college should be available to all students instead of emphasizing college readiness.
Enthusiasm, interest, and aptitude are more important than book smarts.
Don 5 years ago5 years ago
You’re right. Someone without math skills could work collaboratively on a team … just as long as someone else on the team does have the requisite skills.