Black teachers: How to recruit them and make them stay
Lessons in higher education: What California can learn
Keeping California public university options open
Superintendents: Well-paid and walking away
The debt to degree connection
College in prison: How earning a degree can lead to a new life
Calculus is expected to be difficult; it should not be impossible. But, too often, this course becomes a gatekeeper that pushes students out of careers in science, technology, engineering and math — or STEM — fields, especially women and marginalized students.
However, it is not certain types of students, but certain instructional approaches and learning conditions that ensure deeper learning and even enjoyment in college calculus classes.
The evidence is undeniable that math classrooms can support greater success for women and marginalized students, according to a report I recently co-authored. Charting a New Course: Investigating Barriers on the Calculus Pathway to STEM, published by the California Education Learning Lab and Just Equations, is based on a review of more than 200 books, journal articles, research reports, other online and print sources and a dozen interviews.
Preventing calculus from becoming a roadblock for students begins with rethinking traditional assumptions about the types of students who can succeed in STEM fields. Students’ prior preparation influences their performance in college math courses, but not all students have access to the courses that would best position them to succeed in college calculus. And excluding students from STEM fields simply because they haven’t taken the right prep courses reinforces inequity and absolves math faculty of responsibility for the disproportionate numbers of women, Black and Latino students leaving a STEM path after taking calculus.
College math departments have an important role in creating conditions that promote math success for diverse students. Rather than assuming students don’t have what it takes to pursue STEM majors — and putting them through a gauntlet of math prerequisites that few students survive — effective classroom instruction and support can make a difference in calculus success, especially for students with less preparation.
Positive student-faculty rapport plays a central role in students’ success in calculus, as documented in a study by the Mathematical Association of America. Student-centered teaching methods — also known as active learning or inquiry-based learning — devote less time to lecture and more to students working with classmates to interact with mathematical concepts. In one such example, Cal State East Bay’s reformed calculus classes use Wikki Stix to model functions, and trains of dominoes to represent integrals and derivatives.
These approaches help students develop their own conceptual understanding of math topics and promote a higher level of student engagement. They also provide more opportunities for instructors to get to know students and observe their learning to help identify which concepts need reinforcement.
Another piece of the puzzle is fostering students’ math identity and sense of belonging, especially among student groups that have historically been excluded from STEM fields.
“A sense of belonging happens in the classroom,” noted an instructor from a California community college where more than two-thirds of students are from marginalized populations. “If they’re feeling math anxiety, imposter syndrome in their calculus classes, they’re out of there.”
The Emerging Scholars Workshops at the University of California Berkeley popularized support for peer learning networks after founder Uri Treisman saw sharp increases in the success rate of Black students placed in study groups with other Black students, which contributed to a sense of belonging.
For such efforts to succeed, it’s also important to address implicit bias on the part of faculty, through professional development and training for faculty and staff. Explicitly addressing race and gender stereotypes also can support underrepresented students who are more likely to experience math identity issues. One university, for example, found a correlation between participation in a calculus workshop on identity issues and students’ GPAs and STEM persistence. Diversifying STEM departments is another strategy, as research reveals that same-race instructors can increase persistence in STEM among Black students.
Corequisite approaches, in which students enroll in a course while receiving concurrent support, can also improve students’ chances of completing a STEM degree as compared with lengthy sequences of prerequisite courses that students must pass before they reach calculus. Though corequisites have been used more commonly for courses such as college algebra, precalculus, and statistics, there is promising evidence that such courses can also help more students succeed in calculus.
In a similar vein, UC San Diego runs a program called Summer Bridge that serves first-generation and under-resourced students. The credit-bearing program is designed to fill gaps in students’ prior knowledge by providing supplemental instruction and opportunities to engage with instructors or teaching assistants while taking Calculus 1 or other gateway courses.
For too long, STEM classes have been dominated by students who are white, male and privileged. Math departments must acknowledge their responsibility to build a diverse pipeline and address institutional barriers that bar access to STEM for historically excluded groups.
After all, racial equity and global competitiveness will not happen by recruiting better students, but by providing better instruction to serve existing students and attract new ones.
•••
Melodie Baker is national policy director for Just Equations and an author of Charting a New Course: Investigating Barriers on the Calculus Pathway to STEM.
The opinions expressed in this commentary represent those of the author. EdSource welcomes commentaries representing diverse points of view. If you would like to submit a commentary, please review our guidelines and contact us.
A grassroots campaign recalled two members of the Orange Unified School District in an election that cost more than half a million dollars.
Legislation that would remove one of the last tests teachers are required to take to earn a credential in California passed the Senate Education Committee.
Part-time instructors, many who work for decades off the tenure track and at a lower pay rate, have been called “apprentices to nowhere.”
A bill to mandate use of the method will not advance in the Legislature this year in the face of teachers union opposition.
Comments (3)
Comments Policy
We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.
Warn 7 months ago7 months ago
“Regarded as one of the most advanced forms of mathematics, what makes it all the scarier for students is that the math courses they take during school are not nearly as complex. What further contributes to its difficulty is its requirement of a high level of previously studied math e.g algebra concepts.”
I love your content but I have my opinion too: https://educatoroid.com/is-calculus-1-hard/
What’s your Thoughts?
Sarah 9 months ago9 months ago
I disagree with this article. I think the solutions presented are a waste of time and don't actually solve the issue. When people are studying Calculus, what usually causes them to fail falls under three categories: poor study habits, weak foundation in algebra and precalculus, or math anxiety. I've tutored a lot of students and usually when they take an online math course, they aren't even aware that they have a textbook. Then the next issue is … Read More
I disagree with this article. I think the solutions presented are a waste of time and don’t actually solve the issue.
When people are studying Calculus, what usually causes them to fail falls under three categories: poor study habits, weak foundation in algebra and precalculus, or math anxiety.
I’ve tutored a lot of students and usually when they take an online math course, they aren’t even aware that they have a textbook. Then the next issue is that they don’t know how to read one because their high school never used textbooks – relying on worksheets instead. Of course, they also don’t know how to take notes efficiently.
I’ve seen students take pictures of the board or record a lecture if it’s online, and then proceed to never write the content down themselves. Then when they do the homework, they skip doing the example problems so they are lost and incorrectly do the questions. Or they expect to complete the whole homework in an hour, and waited last minute to work on an assignment.
That’s when they come to me.
For some students, they have a poor foundation in the class and it’s harder to fix. I’ve seen students forget some algebra, such as not knowing what to do with logarithms, or how to simplify a complex rational expression. The worst are students who never mastered their multiplication table and instead relied on counting. So the Calculus isn’t the issue, it’s when you simplified it and then need algebra to finish the problem.
These issues are worse now due to the effects of the pandemic on school systems. A lot of students who should have been failed, were passed and inadequately prepared for college.
Robert L Crawford 2 years ago2 years ago
We need to do more to prepare students before College …. anything after that can help but is only a half measure. We need to aim at teaching students Calculus before College!