Credit: Allison Shelley for American Education
A second-grade boy raises his hand during an art class at Wesley Elementary School.

Expanded summer school for K-12 students may be one positive outcome of the pandemic that has contributed to varying levels of learning loss among students across the state.

Without providing details, Gov. Gavin Newsom indicated that he will be including funds in the budget he will present to the Legislature in January that might allow schools to effectively extend the school year into the summer, as a crucial way to help make up for the learning loss that many students have suffered during the pandemic.

“We’re going to be creative to look more broadly outside the previous constructs, this mantra or mindset that goes back to an agrarian society that no longer exists, that has the presumption that 99% of us will be toiling the fields come this summer,” he said during his briefing on his plan to encourage more schools to offer in-person instruction.

He said he didn’t want to “get too far ahead in terms of the budget that we will be submitting,” but that “we will be looking at extending the day, looking at extending into the summer, looking at the opportunity to get tutors and additional supports to comprehensively address learning loss.”

His remarks were reinforced by those of State Board of Education President Linda Darling-Hammond, who is also currently heading up the education transition team for President-elect Joe Biden.

“We need to understand the school year in new ways,” Darling-Hammond said, pointing to a widespread concern among educators for decades that the long summer break can be damaging to the educational progress of many students, especially those who are already struggling. “We’ve been tied to an agrarian calendar for the school year that begins in September or August and goes until May or June.”

But, she said, California shouldn’t be thinking about the instructional calendar as consisting of “what we can we cram in only by May. We should think about this as the continuous process of solving for learning and taking advantage of the many other innovations that are going on in this state.”

These could include everything from outdoor classrooms, expedition schools and project-based learning to interactive online materials that have become regular additions to teacher’s toolboxes.

In general, summer schools are low-budget affairs, typically providing instruction for a small subset of students who have to make up for lost credits that they need to graduate, or to advance to the next grade. As described in this EdSource report, summer schools took a huge hit during the Great Recession a decade ago, and many have never fully recovered. Most summer programs, often described as “enrichment programs,” are private ones that only higher income parents have been able to afford, further widening achievement gaps between higher and lower income students.

A notable exception is the ambitious and creative summer program launched last summer by Los Angeles Unified, which was intended to be accessible to all its students.

Neither Darling-Hammond nor Newsom provided details about what they will be proposing in his January budget. But Newsom stressed that the issue of how to ensure that children catch up and succeed is a major concern of his — like it is of most parents, he said. “I can assure you it is not only top of mind, it’s foundational in terms of the budget that we’ll be submitting for consideration to the legislature.”

To get more reports like this one, click here to sign up for EdSource’s no-cost daily email on latest developments in education.

Share Article

Comments (3)

Leave a Reply to Larry

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * *

Comments Policy

We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.

  1. Bob Capriles 2 months ago2 months ago

    The thought of changing the school calendar raises a number of questions for me. What do teachers currently do during the summer? Some teach summer school (and get paid for their time), others take professional development courses (usually on their dime), others take vacation to recharge (akin to the European model of 6 weeks of annual vacation). What would happen to that time? With our current teacher shortage in California, would extending the … Read More

    The thought of changing the school calendar raises a number of questions for me.

    What do teachers currently do during the summer? Some teach summer school (and get paid for their time), others take professional development courses (usually on their dime), others take vacation to recharge (akin to the European model of 6 weeks of annual vacation). What would happen to that time?

    With our current teacher shortage in California, would extending the school year attract more teachers assuming teachers would be paid for 12 months of employment vs the current 10 months? (Oh yeah, how would that be funded?) Or would it drive away current and prospective teachers? After all, how many entry level jobs offer 26 days of paid vacation and 2 months of unpaid vacation during the summer?

    And what of the students? What are they doing? High school students are often working between June and August. Summer can also be a time for extended family vacations. I even wonder what would happen to the summer camping experience of many Scouts? These are learning opportunities outside of the formal classroom, yet there is learning occurring.

    And as for the process of education, if there is a proposal to change the calendar, why do we continue to promote students based upon their biological age? Perhaps if we are considering this seriously, we should consider promoting students when they are academically ready, not when the calendar says a year has passed. Of course, there are significant equity issues involved here.

    I’m certain parents would welcome the additional “babysitting” services during the summer. As the pandemic has made painfully clear – our education system provides so much more than just academics – there is qualified supervision, mental health and food to name a few of the critical services centered around education.

    So, though I appreciate the discussion, the issue is not easily resolved.

  2. JudiAU 2 months ago2 months ago

    Summer school to reinforce learning should always be any option for students that don’t pass CASSP scores. And any other student who wants to progress should have that option.

  3. Larry 2 months ago2 months ago

    Slowly eroding summer vacation, while education’s crown jewel of Finland moves in the opposite direction. Thank God the unions (for now) can block a full-frontal bait-and-switch. But it won’t last forever. Tomorrow’s finest teachers will take corporate jobs instead.