Photo: Andrew Reed/EdSource
Oakland teachers rally outside City Hall on the third day of the teachers’ strike, Feb. 25, 2019.

Most Americans believe that K-12 schools deserve more money, the federal government should chip in a bigger share of education costs and a college education — especially at community colleges — should be tuition-free, according a nationwide education poll released Tuesday.

The annual poll by Education Next, an education journal that encourages school choice and charter schools, found a record level of bipartisan support for higher pay for teachers. It also recorded a rebound in overall support for charter schools after a precipitous drop among Democrats following the election of President Donald Trump and his selection of Betsy DeVos as his secretary of education.

The lead authors of the poll, Harvard University professors Martin West and Paul Peterson, noted that several Democratic presidential candidates have made proposals to expand the federal budget on education and to dramatically raise teacher salaries key elements of their campaigns.

“The tenor of these provocative ideas is resonating with the American public. Support for increasing teacher pay is higher now than at any point since 2008 and a majority of the public favors more federal funding for local schools,” they said in a press release.

The poll also found Democrats are more receptive since Trump’s election to tax-supported payments for private school tuition for low-income families — an idea that De Vos has promoted — although support among all poll respondents is still not a majority.

In the online poll of 3,046 participants who were identified as willing to participate in periodic polls, 54 percent identified as Democrats, 39 percent as Republicans and 7 percent as independent or affiliated with another party. The poll was conducted in May 2019.

Here’s a summary of the results:

Teacher pay: Support for higher pay, strong among Democrats and Republicans, follows two years of “red for ed” teacher strikes in Los Angeles and Oakland, as well as in the conservative states of West Virginia, Arizona and Oklahoma that stirred public sympathy for teachers. Presidential candidates Bernie Sanders and Kamala Harris both have called for spending tens of billions of dollars to raise teachers’ salaries.

In asking whether teacher pay should rise, stay the same or decrease, Education Next told half of the respondents what teachers in their state earned. Among the “informed,” support for higher pay rose 20 percentage points in two years, to 56 percent, including 64 percent among Democrats and 43 percent among Republicans. Only 5 percent said pay should be cut.

Among those who weren’t told about current pay levels of teachers, 72 percent favored higher pay, including 83 percent of Democrats and 60 percent of Republicans.

Higher state spending: Among those not told current levels of expenditures, 62 percent of respondents favored more spending for K-12, 8 percentage points higher than in 2017. Although only 50 percent of those informed of current levels in their state’s spending favored an increase, that level still is increase of 11 percentage points higher than two years ago.

Federal spending: The federal government contributes about 10 percent of an average school district’s revenue. Most respondents believe that it’s about three times that amount. When informed of the actual amount, 67 percent of respondents called for a larger federal share. That dropped to 60 percent among those who didn’t know the actual contribution.

Among the Democratic presidential candidates, former Vice President Joe Biden has called for federal spending on K-12 to triple. Trump has called for big cuts in general education spending, including Title I for low-income children.

Free college: Several states now offer free community college tuition, including California, although its new two-year College Promise doesn’t include textbooks and other costs. Among respondents, 69 percent supported free community college, including 85 percent of Democrats and 47 percent of Republicans.

Free four-year college got less support: 60 percent overall, broken down to 79 percent of Democrats and 35 percent of Republicans.

Charter schools: In 2016, the last year under President Barack Obama, Education Next found that support for charter schools reached 51 percent, with more Democrats in favor than against. One year later, overall support had dropped to 39 percent, as Democrats flipped.

This year, overall support for charter schools rose to 48 percent, mainly because more Republicans who had expressed no opinion now indicated support, the pollsters said. Democrats remain opposed, with 40 percent backing them and 48 percent against.

School safety. Ed Next polled a separate group of 415 parents about school safety. Only 38 percent felt confident their student’s school provides sufficient security against a shooting attack, while 78 percent said they’d support metal detectors at all entrances and 81 percent supported screening students for emotional distress.

We need your help ...

Unlike many news outlets, EdSource does not secure its content behind a paywall. We believe that informing the largest possible audience about what is working in education — and what isn't — is far more important.

Once a year, however, we ask our readers to contribute as generously as they can so that we can do justice to reporting on a topic as vast and complex as California's education system — from early education to postsecondary success.

Thanks to support from several philanthropic foundations, EdSource is participating in NewsMatch. As a result, your tax-deductible gift to EdSource will be worth three times as much to us — and allow us to do more hard hitting, high-impact reporting that makes a difference. Don’t wait. Please make a contribution now.

Share Article

Comments (5)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * *

Comments Policy

We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.

  1. Roman Makarenko 3 months ago3 months ago

    Totaly agree

  2. Rhea Beashear 3 months ago3 months ago

    I am an early education professional, (Montessori teacher, and a Master’s in Early Childhood Services), and would like to expand the conversation to include thinking about the pay for teachers who support children in childcare and preschool settings. Most teachers make below $13 an hour and assistants make less than $10 even though states require licenses and degrees for classroom professionals. This is for good reason when you understand that the most active and … Read More

    I am an early education professional, (Montessori teacher, and a Master’s in Early Childhood Services), and would like to expand the conversation to include thinking about the pay for teachers who support children in childcare and preschool settings. Most teachers make below $13 an hour and assistants make less than $10 even though states require licenses and degrees for classroom professionals. This is for good reason when you understand that the most active and influential period of brain development is occurring during the years before formal education starts.

    Early Childhood Education centers operate from 7 am to 6 pm each day, year-round, and do not get the extended breaks for holidays. Some of the larger national chain centers can offer benefits like insurance and 401-k plans; but let’s be honest, teachers can’t really afford to take advantage of the benefits when their pay is so low. Our communities need to begin embracing the responsibility for how education occurs at all levels and begin to consider ECE as part of the educational landscape. If the conversation is starting about higher pay for teachers, don’t leave us out.

  3. Roger Levy 3 months ago3 months ago

    1. How do you write an article about teacher pay and not provide any information or comparative statistics that actually describe what teachers are paid? 2. There are at least 30 years of studies that show no relationship between teacher pay and student performance. So unless the purpose here is just to be generous, why is it that teacher pay should be increased? 3. Although the ‘polls’ you passingly reference indicate support for … Read More

    1. How do you write an article about teacher pay and not provide any information or comparative statistics that actually describe what teachers are paid?
    2. There are at least 30 years of studies that show no relationship between teacher pay and student performance. So unless the purpose here is just to be generous, why is it that teacher pay should be increased?
    3. Although the ‘polls’ you passingly reference indicate support for increasing teacher pay, do the responders have any idea what teachers are actually paid? Are the responders aware that after two years most teachers have tenure, which means they are generally incapable of being fired even for gross incompetence? Are the responders aware that only an insignificant percentage of teachers are rewarded for good performance and that the general rule is that both good and bad teachers get the same pay?

  4. Phillip Nagle 3 months ago3 months ago

    Teachers are very well paid despite their constant whining. When one considers that they only work nine months a year during which they get extended Christmas and Spring vacations, a case can be made they are overpaid. Add into the mix very generous retirement benefits and tenure, the case that teachers are overpaid is much stronger than that they are underpaid.

    Replies

    • Sharon Meek 3 months ago3 months ago

      My response to Phillip Nagle is most teachers enter teaching unaware they will be working in underfunded classrooms. We have to pay for a considerable amount of supplies for student and classroom use. Depending on where and whom we teach determines our classroom budgets. Additionally, we aren’t paid for the “vacations” in which you refer to over holidays and summer. In fact, a lot of districts don’t offer extra duty positions for … Read More

      My response to Phillip Nagle is most teachers enter teaching unaware they will be working in underfunded classrooms. We have to pay for a considerable amount of supplies for student and classroom use. Depending on where and whom we teach determines our classroom budgets.

      Additionally, we aren’t paid for the “vacations” in which you refer to over holidays and summer. In fact, a lot of districts don’t offer extra duty positions for summer.

      Teachers often get locked into a school district because if we transfer after a varying number of years we lose money. Most districts seem to accept up to 10 years of service credit, after that the years are lost on the pay scale.

      Teachers aren’t allowed to contribute into Social Security so we aren’t able to draw it upon retirement or receive state disability if injured.We do have strs pension that we fund and the district contributes.

      Another teacher expense, besides having a bachelor’s degree, is a teaching credential (45-60 units) plus additional mandatory professional growth. Continuing our education is expensive. Teachers might “whine” about our salaries because we are expected to nurture all future career fields; yet our society isn’t standing up and taking responsibility for supporting us in our efforts.

      It’s unfortunate more people aren’t appreciative of educators. Gladly, I get rewarded from my students’ reciprocated hard work in my classroom; too bad it doesn’t pay my bills.