Lessons in higher education: What California can learn
Keeping California public university options open
Superintendents: Well-paid and walking away
The debt to degree connection
College in prison: How earning a degree can lead to a new life
Library or police, a small town’s struggle puts a spotlight on library inequities across California
California is the home of some of the nation’s earliest and most influential “out” gay leaders. It’s no surprise then that California has paved the way for teaching gay history in our K-12 schools and that other states are beginning to follow suit.
The 2011 passage of California’s FAIR Education Act mandated that LGBTQ (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer) accomplishments be taught in our history and social studies classrooms in an age-appropriate manner. This law doesn’t teach morality; it teaches our students that gay Americans have been an integral part of our society and continue to shape our current world.
What does teaching gay history look like? In elementary schools, this might be reading a book where a character has two moms or two dads. In secondary education, it can be learning about California’s own Harvey Milk or the gay liberation movement. For teachers, these shifts can seem minimal — after all, more and more teachers are being trained on culturally responsive pedagogy.
However, for students, the impact could be, quite literally, the difference between life and death. Nearly 7 percent of US millennials identify as a member of the gay community. Though there has been social progress in recent history, disparities in how often LGBTQ youth are victimized have not improved since the 1990s. In fact, there has been an uptick in hate crimes in our schools.
One study suggests that each episode of LGBT victimization, such as physical or verbal harassment or abuse, increases the likelihood of self-harming behavior by 2.5 times on average. Student suicides among sexual and gender minorities are still frequent headlines, with gay youth four times as likely to have attempted suicide than their straight peers.
This bullying is impacting both their physical safety and their schoolwork. Academically, higher rates of truancy and lower GPAs have been documented among LGBT students. With lives at stake, it is no wonder that at least two other states have followed California’s lead to ensure that LGBTQ students feel less excluded and LGBTQ history and contributions are part of the school curriculum.
In April of this year, Massachusetts created optional LGBTQ history lessons that may be taught in schools. Additionally, this year, the Illinois State Senate took a historic vote to mandate LGBTQ history be taught in schools through the passage of SB 3249, a bill similar in scope to the FAIR Education Act.
The California FAIR Education Act and Illinois’ SB 3249 won’t solve every problem for our gay youth, but they work to ensure that students have an understanding that our gay students are not alone and build tolerance among their straight peers.
Representation matters. Seeing that there have been gay people throughout American history is an important first step to letting our current students know that they can and will achieve greatness, just as others have done before them.
•••
James Hilton Harrell is a transformational support specialist with WestEd, a nonprofit research, development and service agency and, prior to that, served as a teacher and director of instruction at Oakland Unified School District.
The opinions expressed in this commentary represent those of the author. EdSource welcomes commentaries representing diverse points of view. If you would like to submit a commentary, please review our guidelines and contact us.
Update Dec. 8, 2021 - Fixed a link about the prevalence of suicide and changed the higher risk for LGBTQ youth to "four times as likely" per the data cited in the report to which that sentence is linking.
The system has enrolled more in-state residents, but not enough to meet targets set by the state.
Two prominent organizations say the proposal would dismantle progress made to improve reading instruction for those students.
Fresno City College professor Tom Boroujeni is unable to fulfill his duties as academic senate president while on leave, the latest update reads.
This is a continuing EdSource series on proven innovations in higher education that relate to the problems facing California’s higher education systems.
Comments (6)
Comments Policy
We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.
selena 1 year ago1 year ago
Me personally I've never had nothing against the LGBTQ community. I believe you have every right to be your own person. This is so sad, that people go on living their life in fear of being judged even harassed for just being their self. People will constantly have opinions on people and judge people, but that doesn't mean its okay or make it right to do so! Everyone should be able to like do whatever … Read More
Me personally I’ve never had nothing against the LGBTQ community. I believe you have every right to be your own person. This is so sad, that people go on living their life in fear of being judged even harassed for just being their self. People will constantly have opinions on people and judge people, but that doesn’t mean its okay or make it right to do so! Everyone should be able to like do whatever they want either its physically, or emotionally and not feel ashamed or bashed for it.
Everyone is so beautiful in our own way, being taught the education and the history behind the LGBTQ in schools or by our parents should be normalized!
I don’t really like to characterize the LGBTQ only because at the end they are people I feel like it’s rude. It’s not fair how people are treated for just living their own life, and this needs to change!
Rachael Jesus 4 years ago4 years ago
I’m fine with LGBTQ people, honestly, but this is going too far. This concept of same sex relationship is a value thing, if anyone is going to teach us about LGBTQ it should be our parents, not the government.
And how far is this going to go? What about the religious children, do they get a choice to not learn about this? This shouldn’t be forced upon anyone, especially children.
Edward 4 years ago4 years ago
I have been looking for the source of “One study suggests that each episode of LGBT victimization, such as physical or verbal harassment or abuse, increases the likelihood of self-harming behavior by 2.5 times on average. ” Following through your link to “Am J Public Health. 2010 December; 100(12): 2426–2432.” I do not find measurement of incidents of victimization. Any help on that source? Thanks.
Decker 5 years ago5 years ago
I fully support gay rights, but I think this is a terrible idea. Students have more important things to learn about rather than the left forcing them to acknowledge gay people. I am not homophobic and I don’t think homophobia is a good thing but you’re allowed to be homophobic. It’s completely in your rights to be homophobic, and students need to learn on their own which one they are rather than schools forcing them to believe this.
Staci Blix 5 years ago5 years ago
I’m curious if there is specific curriculum that identifies what is to be taught and when? I’m involved in an online debate with some people who are upset that California is teaching about “sexual relations” in history class, but nobody seems to have any clue what the curriculum actually looks like. I wonder if there is anything specific about what is taught at different grade levels?
Jimmy Franco 5 years ago5 years ago
How would you suggest to combat conservative religious talking points in a community that says sexuality discussions aren’t appropriate for the classroom? Thank you.