The Los Angeles Unified School District will provide $150 million in additional funding to 50 “high-needs” schools over the next three years under an agreement that settles a lawsuit that alleged that district officials misspent hundreds of millions in state funding intended to help English learners, foster youth and students from low-income families.
The suit was filed two years ago by ACLU of Southern California, the nonprofit law firm Public Advocates and Covington & Burling LLP on behalf of L.A. Unified parent Reyna Frias and the Los Angeles-based Community Coalition, a nonprofit advocacy organization. It charged that the district improperly reduced the amount of money it should have spent on “high-needs” students — low-income students, foster youth, homeless students and English learners — under the 2013 Local Control Funding Formula.
The suit said the district was improperly reducing its obligation to those high-needs students by spending $450 million annually for federally mandated services for special education students who are also high-needs students and counting that as meeting its obligation under the funding formula.
“This case sets an important precedent — a message that will discourage school districts throughout the state from misspending local control funding,” said John Affeldt, a managing attorney at the San Francisco-based Public Advocates.
David Holmquist, general counsel for L.A. Unified, said the district is ready to “move forward.”
“The result of this settlement provides a tremendous opportunity to direct more resources to our highest-need students and schools,” he said. “The underlying litigation between the parties involved varying interpretations of a very complex statutory framework.”
The lawsuit, filed in 2015, argued that the funding formula mandates that the district increase and improve programs and services, such as hiring counselors or creating smaller classes, beyond what state and federal laws separately obligated the district to spend for special education. District officials have argued that the accounting was fair because 79 percent of the students who receive special education services also fall into at least one of the four high-needs groups.
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson agreed with the Public Advocates and other complainants in an August 2016 ruling that addressed the 2015 lawsuit. The ruling requires the district to adjust its budget by the 2017-18 school year.
The settlement paves the way for the district to comply with that ruling and create an annual Local Control Accountability Plan, required under the law, that includes an additional $150 million for the 50 schools over three years.
”This is a tremendous victory for high-need students,” said Aurea Montes-Rodriguez, executive vice-president of Community Coalition. “The settlement will allow us to continue a process of working with the district to address equity issues for the current and upcoming academic years to help it change the way it allocates funding.”
However, Bruce Fuller, a UC Berkeley professor who has conducted research both for L.A. Unified and for advocacy groups involved in the dispute, said the settlement fell short of what he expected.
“The amount of money is disappointing, compared to the state’s ruling that the district has shortchanged these kids by between $270 million and $450 million a year over the past four years,” he said.
However, Fuller noted that the Community Coalition and the Advancement Project — a social justice organization with offices in Washington D.C. and Los Angeles — identified the 50 neediest schools.
“It takes a sizable step toward an equity formula,” he said.
|Edwin Markham Middle||Middle|
|Barack Obama Global Preparation Academy||Middle|
|Horace Mann Junior High||Middle|
|Samuel Gompers Middle||Middle|
|Dr. Julian Nava Learning Academies-School of Arts and Culture||Middle|
|Dr. Julian Nava Learning Academies-School of Business and Technology||Middle|
|George Washington Carver Middle||Middle|
|John Muir Middle||Middle|
|Bret Harte Preparatory Middle||Middle|
|John H. Liechty Middle||Middle|
|Sal Castro Middle||Middle|
|Charles Maclay Middle||Middle|
|Los Angeles Academy Middle||Middle|
|William Jefferson Clinton Middle||Middle|
|Mary McLeod Bethune Middle||Middle|
|Johnnie Cochran, Jr. Middle||Middle|
|Charles Drew Middle||Middle|
|Crenshaw Science, Technology, Engineering, Math and Medicine Magnet||High|
|NAVA College Preparatory Academy||High|
|Sylmar Biotech Health Academy||High|
|Manual Arts Senior High||High|
|Humanitas Academy of Art and Technology at Esteban E. Torres High No. 4||High|
|David Starr Jordan Senior High||High|
|Augustus F. Hawkins High B Community Health Advocales||High|
|Santee Education Complex||High|
|Dr. Maya Angelou Community High||High|
|Academy for Multilingual Arts and Science at Mervyn M. Dymally High||High|
|Augustus F. Hawkins High C Responsible Indigenous Social Entrepreneurship||High|
|Foshay Learning Center||High|
|Augustus F. Hawkins High A Critical Design and||High|
|Robert Fulton College Preparatory||High|
|East Valley Senior High||High|
|Sun Valley High||High|
|Susan Miller Dorsey Senior High||High|
|Theodore Roosevelt Senior High||High|
|George Washington Preparatory High||High|
|Performing Arts Community at Diego Rivera Learning Complex||High|
|Gardena Senior High||High|
|Communication and Technology at Diego Rivera Leaming Complex||High|
|Thomas Jefferson Senior High||High|
|Helen Bernstein High||High|
|Engineering and Technology Academy at Esteban E. Torres High No. 3||High|
|Los Angeles River at Sonia Sotomayor Learning Academies||High|
|Edward R. Roybal Learning Center||High|
|RFK Community Schools-Ambassador-Global Leadership||High|
|Public Service Community at Diego Rivera Learning Complex||High|
Support independent journalism
If this article helped keep you informed and engaged with California education, would you consider supporting the nonprofit organization that brought it to you?
EdSource is participating in NewsMatch, a campaign to keep independent, nonprofit journalism strong. A gift to EdSource now means your donation will be matched, dollar for dollar, up to $1,000 per donation through the end of 2018. That means double the support for the reporters, editors and data specialists who brought you this story. Please make a contribution today.