On a split vote, Oakland Unified trustees voted Wednesday to revoke the three charters of the long-controversial American Indian Model Schools, citing the organization’s failure to resolve charges of self-dealing involving its founder and former executive director, the Oakland Tribune reported. The three schools, serving students from elementary through high school, will close after this school year. But the vote won’t end the saga; parents have vowed to appeal the decision to the State Board if necessary.

Last year, after a whistleblower’s complaint, an investigation by a state agency found $3.8 million in questionable expenditures of public money by Ben Chavis, the schools’ founder, and his wife, who also served as bookkeeper. Among questionable expenses were $850,000 in yearly rent – five times Oakland Unified’s rate – on property that Chavis owned, consulting contracts and other services. The report was turned over to the county attorney’s office, which continues to investigate the case. The district gave American Indian 60 days to institute reforms and management controls. Though Chavis no longer is directly associated with the school, he remained the landlord. District Superintendent Tony Smith said the changes by the school’s board of directors were insufficient.

The schools consistently have had among the highest test scores in the state. The first American Indian charter school served some native Americans when it opened but in recent years Asian students comprised 70 percent of the students.

 

Share Article

Comments (3)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * *

Comments Policy

We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.

  1. CarolineSF 6 years ago6 years ago

    Jay Mathews of the Washington Post just wrote an outraged blog post calling on OUSD not to shut the charters down and calling the American Indian high school the best high school in America.

  2. Paul 6 years ago6 years ago

    Unbelievable! Thanks for pointing this out, CarolineSF. It is also well worth reading the reports that led to the revocation of the charter. Related-party financial transactions, insufficient teacher credentials, non-response to official information requests, and deficient board meeting records are all documented. Go to http://ousd.legistar.com/Legislation.aspx , enter "12-2557" (without the quotes) in the "Search" box, and then select "Search Legislation". Read More

    Unbelievable! Thanks for pointing this out, CarolineSF.

    It is also well worth reading the reports that led to the revocation of the charter. Related-party financial transactions, insufficient teacher credentials, non-response to official information requests, and deficient board meeting records are all documented. Go to http://ousd.legistar.com/Legislation.aspx , enter “12-2557” (without the quotes) in the “Search” box, and then select “Search Legislation”.