Black teachers: How to recruit them and make them stay
Lessons in higher education: What California can learn
Keeping California public university options open
Superintendents: Well-paid and walking away
The debt to degree connection
College in prison: How earning a degree can lead to a new life
In 2012, it was called Operation Glasshouse, an undercover drug investigation at three Riverside County high schools that resulted in the arrest of 22 students. Two years later, it was known as the high school drug sting that caused some California school districts to lose their enthusiasm for high school drug stings.
Now a Riverside County Superior Court judge has dismissed the lawsuit at the center of the controversy around Operation Glasshouse. The 2013 suit was brought by Jesse Snodgrass, who was a 17-year-old Chaparral High School senior with autism when he was arrested as part of the sting. The suit alleged that the Temecula Valley Unified School District had breached its mandatory duties by allowing a deputy from the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department to manipulate Snodgrass – a friendless student who had bipolar disorder, trouble keeping up with conversations and a history of being bullied – as part of an undercover drug sting.
On Monday, Catherine Snodgrass, Jesse’s mother, said her son would appeal the ruling. “The judge is giving the administration free rein and that’s troubling,” she said.
The lawsuit was the first in California to try to hold a school district responsible for protecting students in special education from allegedly being manipulated in a police drug sting, according to Snodgrass’s lawyer, Wendy Housman.
But in a ruling filed with the court on Nov. 10, Judge Raquel A. Marquez found the district not liable for damages, stating that district officials had not worked with the sheriff’s department to deliberately target Snodgrass. In addition, Marquez ruled, district officials had immunity from liability for two reasons: because they were cooperating with police and because California Government Code 820.2 protects public employees who are making routine policy decisions.
The dismissal of the case by the judge “validates that the district’s level of involvement in the undercover operation was only to cooperate with law enforcement,” the Temecula Valley Unified School District said in a statement.
Undercover high school drug stings have been happening across the nation since before President Richard Nixon declared “a war on drugs” in 1971, said Stephen Downing, a retired deputy chief with the Los Angeles Police Department who ran the department’s narcotics enforcement program from 1973 to 1977. Downing is now a national board member of Law Enforcement Against Prohibition, a criminal justice group that aims to end the war on drugs, and has closely followed the Snodgrass case.
But most students who are arrested do not file suit contesting their arrest, Downing said. “People fear standing up to a district attorney,” he said. The Snodgrass lawsuit provided a rare look at the workings of an undercover high school drug sting and launched a barrage of negative publicity about Operation Glasshouse, including a 2014 Rolling Stone magazine piece titled “The Entrapment of Jesse Snodgrass,” and a video by the Vice Media group titled “The War on Kids.”
In March 2014, the Drug Policy Alliance, a nonprofit advocacy group, sent a letter to all school districts in Riverside County alerting officials to recent school drug stings, the alleged targeting of special needs students and a California Department of Education investigation into Temecula Valley Unified School District’s process for expelling students in special education.
The publicity “has resulted in Riverside and San Bernardino not doing the drug stings anymore,” Downing said. The Riverside County Sheriff’s Department confirmed that it did not conduct high school drug stings in 2014 and has no plans to do so in 2015, according to department spokesman Deputy Armando Muñoz. San Bernardino Sheriff’s Department spokeswoman Deputy Olivia Bozek said that there have been no high school drug stings in the county “in the last couple of years.” (See table below for a list of recent high school undercover drug operations.)
Undercover drug stings were ended in the Los Angeles Unified School District in 2005, after concerns that the stings did not lead to the arrest of drug dealers, were difficult to prosecute because of allegations of entrapment and often targeted students who had special needs and emotional issues.
“Instead of the guy slinging dope on campus, you wind up with a random collection of whichever kids might be naive, stupid, persuadable or gullible enough to find a joint for a stranger,” said Kevin Reed, LA Unified’s legal counsel at the time, in a Los Angeles Times opinion piece.
Law enforcement agencies have initiated school drug stings because the arrests “added to their statistics,” and the agencies could use those statistics when they applied for federal grants, said Downing. A 2013 American Civil Liberties Union Report, The War on Marijuana in Black and White, noted that the federal Edward Byrne Memorial State and Local Law Enforcement Assistance Program disperses about $250 million a year to jurisdictions across the country for law enforcement activities, which are evaluated in part through the number of people arrested.
But the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department said that the drug stings were not related to a drive to increase the number of arrests. “Department funding is not affected by drug arrest statistics,” Muñoz said.
As described in the lawsuit, Snodgrass and other students, including about six students in special education, were befriended by an undercover deputy sheriff known as “Dan,” who allegedly badgered them into buying small amounts of drugs for him. According to Catherine Snodgrass, Jesse was new to Chaparral High, lacked the ability to pick up on social cues because of his autism and made only one friend in his first semester – Dan, who introduced himself to Jesse on the first day of school and talked with him in graphics art class.
In 60 text messages, Dan implored Jesse to find him marijuana, the suit said, and he gave Jesse a $20 bill with which to do so. Off-campus in September 2012, about a month after school started, Jesse approached a man who appeared to be homeless, paid $20 for a plastic bag containing enough marijuana for half a joint and then delivered the bag to Dan, the suit said. Dan gave him another $20 for marijuana a month later and Jesse returned to the homeless man and made another small purchase.
“When you have special needs, you’ll do anything for a friend,” Catherine Snodgrass said.
On Dec. 11, 2012, a swarm of officers entered Temecula Valley High, Chaparral High and Rancho Vista High and arrested the students, who were each charged with a felony for possession for sale of a controlled substance. The officers seized marijuana, cocaine, methamphetamine, ecstasy, heroin, LSD and illegal prescription drugs. The sheriff’s department declined to disclose the amounts of drugs seized.
All 22 students were expelled from school. Snodgrass later had his expulsion overturned by an administrative law judge who ruled that the district had left Snodgrass “to fend for himself, anxious and alone, against an undercover police officer” and that Snodgrass “has overwhelmingly demonstrated that his actions were a manifestation of his disability.”
A judge granted Snodgrass extenuating circumstances for the felony charge and he was given six months of probation.
Brendan Hamme, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California who has followed the Snodgrass case, said that the drug stings in Los Angeles Unified and Temecula Valley Unified “are by and large representative” of typical high school drug stings. The stings involve small quantities of drugs and “students with disabilities, loners who have difficulty making friends, or students who use marijuana themselves but aren’t dealers by any stretch,” he said.
Despite the dismissal of the Snodgrass case, Hamme said, “the suit is indicative of a growing wave of resistance to these drug stings.”
A grassroots campaign recalled two members of the Orange Unified School District in an election that cost more than half a million dollars.
Legislation that would remove one of the last tests teachers are required to take to earn a credential in California passed the Senate Education Committee.
Part-time instructors, many who work for decades off the tenure track and at a lower pay rate, have been called “apprentices to nowhere.”
A bill to mandate use of the method will not advance in the Legislature this year in the face of teachers union opposition.
Comments (12)
Comments Policy
We welcome your comments. All comments are moderated for civility, relevance and other considerations. Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy.
Anon 4 years ago4 years ago
ACAB this is entrapment. The police are bullies.
Lin 5 years ago5 years ago
Textbook entrapment. They should be ashamed.
Neil 6 years ago6 years ago
This is just another example of how ludicrous Americans sound when using statements like, "the land of the free" in describing their country. 1 in 4 people imprisoned in the world are incarcerated in US prisons, making an ironic mockery of this statement. Admittedly this is just one yardstick among many seeing the US slip further behind the rest of the developed world, while incredibly a host of completely unrelated issues (ie immigration) are blamed. … Read More
This is just another example of how ludicrous Americans sound when using statements like, “the land of the free” in describing their country. 1 in 4 people imprisoned in the world are incarcerated in US prisons, making an ironic mockery of this statement. Admittedly this is just one yardstick among many seeing the US slip further behind the rest of the developed world, while incredibly a host of completely unrelated issues (ie immigration) are blamed. How long is it going to take Americans to awaken to the Orwellian normality now pervading their country?
Nikki 6 years ago6 years ago
Undercover drug sting in high schools? I absolutely welcome it in my child's high school (or anything other). The reality is, which is actually the bigger picture, that drugs have no place in our schools. Law officials need to do what they need to do to fight this war. The fight isn't always going to be a pretty, but the potential results outweigh the minimal mishaps. Perhaps there just needs to be guidelines when officers … Read More
Undercover drug sting in high schools? I absolutely welcome it in my child’s high school (or anything other). The reality is, which is actually the bigger picture, that drugs have no place in our schools. Law officials need to do what they need to do to fight this war. The fight isn’t always going to be a pretty, but the potential results outweigh the minimal mishaps. Perhaps there just needs to be guidelines when officers are investigating special needs youth. But please don’t be blinded into thinking that drug dealers don’t recruit special needs youth too.
Replies
Gabriel 6 years ago6 years ago
What potential results? Over $1 trillion spent, and millions of destroyed lives later and the War on Drugs hasn't accomplished any of its stated objectives. Drugs are cheaper, purer, and more available than ever before. Meanwhile a Prison-Industrial complex has emerged wherein prison guard unions and for-profit prison companies lobby for longer sentences, and stricter laws without regard for long term rehabilitation. We have seen the US prison population skyrocket starting in the 1970s. The … Read More
What potential results? Over $1 trillion spent, and millions of destroyed lives later and the War on Drugs hasn’t accomplished any of its stated objectives. Drugs are cheaper, purer, and more available than ever before. Meanwhile a Prison-Industrial complex has emerged wherein prison guard unions and for-profit prison companies lobby for longer sentences, and stricter laws without regard for long term rehabilitation.
We have seen the US prison population skyrocket starting in the 1970s. The US now incarcerates more people per capita than any other nation on Earth, with only 5% of the world’s population we have 25% of the world’s prisoners. A more blatant example of how this undermines inmate rehabilitation would be the “Cash for Kids” case in Pennsylvania, where a judge received over a million in bribes from Juvenile Detention Center developers to hand down excessively harsh sentences to juveniles (destroying thousands of lives). There is a racial aspect as well, while white and black men use and sell drugs at roughly the same rates, the average black male is 571% more likely to be incarcerated for that behavior.
I would like to challenge you to do a couple of things:
1. Truly empathize with the millions of vulnerable human beings and families who have had their lives destroyed by these policies.
2. Find one metric that indicates the War on Drugs will ever actually prevent people from accessing illegal substances.
Seriously? 6 years ago6 years ago
While your motives are well-intentioned, I urge you to educate yourself on the actual effectiveness of these operations. Not only do these stings target troubled, yet otherwise harmless individuals, but they in no way target the actual dealers of these drugs. If you don't cut out the dealers, you simply leave room for another curious student to find them and become the middleman. Say your child wants to buy weed from a friend. He/she'll ask … Read More
While your motives are well-intentioned, I urge you to educate yourself on the actual effectiveness of these operations. Not only do these stings target troubled, yet otherwise harmless individuals, but they in no way target the actual dealers of these drugs. If you don’t cut out the dealers, you simply leave room for another curious student to find them and become the middleman.
Say your child wants to buy weed from a friend. He/she’ll ask their friends. If they can’t provide it, your child doesn’t just magically deduce that they can’t buy weed anymore, they simply go looking for another source. Would you rather them look to a friend, or someone that considers themself a drug dealer by trade?
That’s not even mentioning the potential for police corruption, abuse of legislation and loopholes. Did you notice that the department declined to report the actual amount of drugs seized in this operation? It’s because they seized damn near nothing, and want to mislead you with their ‘incredibly successful report’ of having seized “marijuana, cocaine, methamphetamine, ecstasy, heroin, LSD and illegal prescription drugs”.
If people are seeking out drugs, they should be helped (you don’t have to automatically give them a free-pass, but you can’t treat them the same as dealers who intend to sell their ‘stock’). If they are selling these drugs, then they are the ones that should be targeted. I assure you that none of these high-school kids (whose education, and potentially lives, were destroyed, or at least greatly hindered thanks to this fiasco) were dealers with connections and the intent to run a business.
Eliminate the dealers, and the middlemen don’t have anyone to be the middleman for. It’s the simple “hang ’em all, it’s illegal, right?” mindset that makes this situation worse and worse — not only for these kids, but their families, the communities whose police forces focus on issues of unimportance, and, of course, the taxpayers (ie you).
Jaimee 6 years ago6 years ago
Hi Nikki, Please take a moment to watch the VICE documentary on this subject. From your statement I would guess that your children are in the percentage that have full cognitive functions and ability to make rational decisions and follow instructions to the letter. Jesse did not - Jesse was targeted and trapped by a much older person. The VICE doc also goes on to show two of the other students who were in the … Read More
Hi Nikki,
Please take a moment to watch the VICE documentary on this subject.
From your statement I would guess that your children are in the percentage that have full cognitive functions and ability to make rational decisions and follow instructions to the letter. Jesse did not – Jesse was targeted and trapped by a much older person. The VICE doc also goes on to show two of the other students who were in the same operation. Dan chose them because of their weaknesses and inability to make rational decisions. It also speaks with a retired cop who pretty much says all that you need to hear.
Yes drug use in schools needs to be prevented – but my entrapment and lies?!
Or perhaps you just came to comment without reading the article!?
Lin 5 years ago5 years ago
Yes Jaimee, people need to see it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8af0QPhJ22s&t=463s
Eugene Fielder 7 years ago7 years ago
If these kids have not been in any other trouble, couldn't theses charges be expunged from there record? Although it may be in a record, couldn't these records be sealed? I do not condone drug use but this is ridiculous. Couldn't some of these high-powered lawyers represent them gratis. Not to sue the cities involved but to try and correct a wrong. I raised three children. Two are now parents. I am sure they made … Read More
If these kids have not been in any other trouble, couldn’t theses charges be expunged from there record? Although it may be in a record, couldn’t these records be sealed? I do not condone drug use but this is ridiculous. Couldn’t some of these high-powered lawyers represent them gratis. Not to sue the cities involved but to try and correct a wrong.
I raised three children. Two are now parents. I am sure they made mistakes and in fact I am sure of it. But this is just so wrong.
Dylan Pheifer 8 years ago8 years ago
Could I get a recent update on this case? It has caught my eye, and I want to be informed so I can help prevent this behavior by speaking against it as well.
Replies
Ryan 7 years ago7 years ago
Indeed, I would like to know as well. This is a perfect example of police entrapment! These situations result in a lot of lost faith in our law enforcement , and government. It is really sad knowing the father of Jesse Snodgrass, Doug, died shortly after.
Lavinia 8 years ago8 years ago
Who is protecting our kids really? Am I to think that my kid might be set up at school not by the bad guys but the police! How proud you must be to serve and protect. I have a special needs kid and I am protecting him!