With long-term consequences, community college students struggle to pass college-level math courses

Math instructor, David Ellingson, teaches differential calculus at Napa Valley College. Photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice.

Math instructor, David Ellingson, teaches a course in differential equations at Napa Valley College. Photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice.

Large numbers of community college students are struggling to pass the college-level math classes they need to complete a degree or transfer to a four-year institution, with long-term implications for their futures.

Success in these more advanced courses represents a continuing challenge for the 112-campus California Community College system.  Although results in individual colleges vary, completion rates across the system have remained virtually unchanged during the past two decades,

According to an EdSource analysis, in the fall of 2010, 45 percent of students taking college-level math courses at California’s 112 community colleges received a failing grade below a “C” or dropped the class before the end of term.

Especially worrisome to educators are the even lower math success rates among African American students across the system, with a 41 percent course success rate, and Hispanic students, with a 49 percent success rate.

Without the required math courses, students may be permanently handicapped in their pursuit of degrees in higher education.

Arthur Winings, 25, of San Jose, a part-time student who works at an Apple “Genius Bar” dispensing technical advice, hopes that won’t be the case in his so-far elusive pursuit of an associate degree.  He has failed pre-calculus twice, a course he needs in order to earn a degree in Information Systems from San Jose Community College.

He said part of the problem is that math instruction “felt mechanical” in his previous classes.  “I didn’t get an explanation of how the math would be practical,” he said.  But he hasn’t given up and plans to try to pass the class a third time.

Less attention to college-level courses

In the drive to improve community college success rates, most attention has been focused on students taking the remedial or “developmental” courses they need just to be eligible to take college-level math courses.  Much less attention has been devoted to students taking college-level courses for which they need for their degrees.

At a minimum, students are required to pass an Intermediate Algebra class to get an associate’s degree, or demonstrate proficiency on a math placement test.  To transfer to a four-year university, more advanced math classes are required as well.

These realities are forcing community colleges to examine the way they teach math.  At the recent annual conference of the California Mathematics Council Community Colleges in Monterey, math instructors from across the system discussed a range of strategies, including helping students understand math concepts rather than focusing on formulas, and tying math instruction more closely to the courses of study students are pursuing.

Said Santa Rosa Junior College student Jesse Cohen, who has tutored his fellow math students, “Students need more of the why, not only the how and the what.”

Making classes relevant

Making math classes more relevant has become a priority of leading community college administrators. Barry Russell, the community colleges’ vice chancellor of academic affairs, said that in welding classes, for example, many students don’t understand that welding has a “huge of amount of trigonometry in it.”  Math classes, he said, should feature examples specifically related to welding, as well as to other fields that involve math skills, from business to medicine. “If we’re going to require math, then making the connections is more of what we should be about,” Russell said.

The make-up of the community college student population also contributes to low completion rates.  Many students either did not do well in math in high school, or are older and have forgotten what they learned. More than in many other subject areas, students approach math with high anxiety, which interferes with their learning.   Many delay taking a math class until they are too far along in their studies, while others are eager to get the math requirement over with, and end up taking classes beyond their capabilities.

They may also hold down multiple jobs and have children to support, giving them little time to seek extra help.

Some students at risk of failing math admit they are floundering and could use more support.  “I don’t have a great understanding of concepts of math,” said Amelia Meyers, 31, a Solano Community College student enrolled in Intermediate Algebra.  She is a military veteran who didn’t make it through the class last summer and is making another attempt this semester.  But it is tough going, she said.

“When I try to learn it on my own, it’s very difficult,” said Meyers, who is studying for a career in fashion design. “When I ask for help, I don’t get one-on-one help like you’d get in high school.”

Success rates vary

Success rates vary widely depending on the college. For example, 66 percent of students at Napa Valley College successfully completed their college-level math classes in the fall of 2010, and 69 percent did at Merritt College in Oakland. In contrast, at West Hills College Coalinga only 34 percent of students successfully completed their math classes, and only 36 percent did so at West Los Angeles Community College.

Because each of California’s community colleges offers different courses and exams, it is not possible to directly compare success rates among colleges. Variations could reflect differences in curriculum and how courses are taught, how leniently or harshly professors grade their students, and how prepared students are when they begin a class.

When students avail themselves of extra help, it makes a difference.

Luis Rodriguez, 20, works on math problems in the computer lab at Napa Valley College. Photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice

Luis Rodriguez, 20, works on math problems in the computer lab at Napa Valley College. Photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice

“I took one calculus course, and it really beat my butt,” said Luis Rodriguez, 20, a student at Napa Valley College, recalling that he got a failing D grade in the course when he took it during his first year.

He then signed up for the Mathematics Engineering Science Achievement (MESA) program, which he said offers a supportive “family-like” environment, and brought his grade up to an A the second time around.

The program, which is targeted at “educationally disadvantaged” students, is housed in a windowless basement around the back of a building.  But these less than luxurious offices are crammed with services designed to help students succeed.  Among its offerings are orientation sessions, extra tutoring, counseling, career advice, and field trips to work sites.

Another approach is to offer a more intensive math class that covers more ground more quickly, based on the “immersion” principle adopted in foreign language instruction. Some students now take several courses – from remedial math, through beginning and intermediate algebra – before they can pass the statistics class that they might need for admission to the next school.

“If you have to take four courses before you can transfer, that’s four hoops to jump through, and at every hoop, you lose people,” said Joseph Conrad, chair of the math department at Solano Community College.

Adding to the challenge is that two years ago, the community colleges increased the difficulty of the minimum level of math competency from Elementary Algebra to Intermediate Algebra.

Barbara Illowsky, chairperson of the Mathematics Department at De Anza College in Cupertino and past-president of the California Mathematics Council Community Colleges, said the Intermediate Algebra standards were the result of a 10-year effort.  She said that research showed students from community colleges weren’t advancing in the workplace because they didn’t have the skills they needed to carry out even basic math operations.

When the new requirement was being debated, “a lot of colleges were concerned that some of our most needy students wouldn’t be able to meet the requirement,” said Sue Nelson, vice president of instruction at Napa Valley College.

To help them, Napa expanded its Math Center services, added computers and bolstered tutoring and support groups.   But like all community colleges, it has been hit by severe budget cuts.  Randy Villa, chair of Napa’s Math Department, said the college is down three full-time instructors, and part-time, adjunct faculty members make up  just over half of the department’s teaching staff.

Villa adds that a nearly $4 million, five-year federal grant to increase the number of Latino students who pursue courses of study in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) will make a big difference. The grant will allow his department to add a new classroom and hire a full-time bilingual math instructor, he said, as well as bolster student services and faculty development.

The college has also ramped up its efforts to identify students with learning disabilities. If left undiagnosed, said Rebecca Scott, Dean of Napa’s Library and Learning Center, students are at risk of ending up with a job where, instead of being able to apply math concepts, they will be asking, “Do you want fries with that?”

Filed under: None


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment Policy

EdSource encourages a robust debate on education issues and welcomes comments from our readers.

  • To preserve a civil dialogue, writers should avoid personal, gratuitous attacks and invective.
  • Comments should be relevant to the subject of the article responded to.
  • EdSource retains the right not to publish inappropriate and offensive comments.
  • EdSource encourages commenters to use their real names. Commenters who do decide to use a pseudonym should use it consistently.
  • Please limit comments to 250 words to prevent comment clutter; if you intend to say more please link out to a place that contains your full comment.
  • Comments with more than one link automatically enter moderation. Comments from new commenters are automatically moderated.
  • Repeated violation of this comment policy will lead to a warning. Continued violations will lead to a ban.

9 Responses to “With long-term consequences, community college students struggle to pass college-level math courses”

EdSource does not track who "likes or dislikes" a comment. We only track the number of likes and dislikes.

  1. Keith on Mar 3, 2015 at 9:41 pm03/3/2015 9:41 pm

    • 000

    I’m a few credits away from an associates degree, but need algebra 101 & perhaps another remedial math class- I live in LIC & work in Manhattan- are there any small inexpensive community college type schools willing to offer these class independent of a particular program?

  2. Jon on Nov 5, 2014 at 5:21 pm11/5/2014 5:21 pm

    • 000

    I’m failing in Math 131/Intermediate Algebra around a 60% raw score. It’s my first year in Pasadena City College and I seem to be failing in my Math class the most and I only got 2 more test and a final exam to pass the class. Even passing with a C grade will still put me in academic probation. I wanted to get my Associates degree and transfer to a CSU or UC to earn my Bachelors degree in Media Arts and Design. Every time I get a low score on my exams, I felt more distraught and the fear of failing will keep me back. I need to improve, to do better. But, how can I do it if I can’t get myself in the right mindset? What am I missing? What am I really doing wrong here that’s holding me back from getting a good grade in Math 131? I need some help.

  3. George DeMarse on Oct 3, 2014 at 7:51 am10/3/2014 7:51 am

    • 000

    You’re darn tootin’. The educators and politicians seem to be on an entirely different page than the college students with regard to math education. The educators want “more math” and “more rigorous” math to be forced on students who want “less math” and “optional math” to boot. Since the students are the ultimate consumers of college education, they should decide whether they want the math or not.

    Several of the comments here are right on target. Why take a group of students who generally hated high school math and did poorly, and force them to do it all over again–only make it harder? It makes no sense. Those who wish to stay away from math should be allowed to do so.

    George DeMarse
    Wake Forest, NC

  4. ricardo castaneda on May 13, 2014 at 11:44 pm05/13/2014 11:44 pm

    • 22100

    this is total bull. why is it that most of us who struggled to pass the math in high school have to return to taking it in college, it’s like having someone who already broke his leg and is finally healed, to going and breaking them again, just to see him limp around on his crutches. the system is more of parasites who find it easier to get money from poor bastards who don’t need the refresher, just the damn studies they need for the career and degree. i hate the math system

  5. Kate on Apr 20, 2014 at 9:48 pm04/20/2014 9:48 pm

    • 22100

    I think requiring college students to take general education is just a way for colleges to take more money from students’ pockets and make student loans larger… this is why. In high school you go over all the subjects, if you are in college, why do you need a refresher? In my opinion, college should be just about your major alone. I want to be a middle school history teacher, the only math I will use in life will be basic adding, taxes, or interest rates. I will not need to calculate statistics, I will not need to do algebraic equations, and I will not need to calculate any volumes for my major.. It seems ridiculous to me. Math is very important for some jobs like astronomy, mathematicians, engineers, and etc. but not for others. I hate the system.

  6. Kristi Garrett on Feb 9, 2012 at 10:11 am02/9/2012 10:11 am

    • 000

    Khan Academy offers hundreds of video tutorials free online that have helped students finally understand concepts that were holding them back. See khanacademy.org

  7. Chris Stampolis on Feb 9, 2012 at 7:18 am02/9/2012 7:18 am

    • 000

    A California Community College Associate of Arts or Associate of Science degree is not just a piece of paper. The degree is supposed to signify that a student has completed the equivalent of the first two years of studies at a four-year university.

    For a degree, there is no in-between.

    A Freshman-credit English course at a California Community College is considered equivalent to a Freshman English course at UC Berkeley or Cal State Fullerton. When a student transfers from Community College to University, that student is expected to have comparable proficiency to students at the receiving university – including demonstrated scholarship in mathematics and sciences.

    Advanced math studies take work. College studies demand diligence. Succeeding in college is not just about showing up. It’s like the phrase “pay me now or pay me later.” Students who don’t learn the basics in elementary, middle and high school will have to catch up before they can earn transferable college credit. We should be grateful Associate Degrees require high standards; our tax monies should empower solid levels of achievement.

    – Chris Stampolis
    Trustee, West Valley-Mission Community College District
    State Board Member, California Community College Trustees (CCCT)
    stampolis@aol.com * 408-390-4748


    • Adv. Math is Unnecessary for Most Jobs on Feb 9, 2012 at 9:47 pm02/9/2012 9:47 pm

      • 020

      Actually, advanced mathematics is unnecessary for most jobs. I studied through Calculus B/C in high school, earned an “A” grade and a “5” on the AP, and essentially never used anything beyond geometry in over a decade and a half of jobs in a variety of fields.

      To require all community college students to pass Intermediate Algebra at the same time the state is slashing classes and support services is a recipe for guaranteed failure.

      California should focus more resources on making sure that students learn Pre-Algebra, Beginning Algebra, and Geometry during K-12, skills that are of near-universal applicability, and on providing all necessary individualized support for those students who wish to pursue Intermediate Algebra and above to attain full mastery, not just passage. Having a larger pool of well-qualified graduates would benefit employers in the technology sector much more than forcing everyone to learn subjects they aren’t interested in, won’t use, and will forget later anyway.

      Investment in middle school foreign language programs also would have wider usefulness and provide greater benefit to the economy and society at large, as compared to requirements that prevent otherwise-qualified students from graduating and becoming productive taxpayers. One of the reasons why foreign language performance by students is so poor is that the first opportunity for courses is often in high school, whereas developmental studies clearly show that language acquisition becomes categorically more difficult as children progress in age.

      • Bill on Nov 5, 2012 at 4:10 pm11/5/2012 4:10 pm

        • -11-100

        I don’t think expecting students to master high school level mathematics (which includes those topics coverred in intermediate algebra) is too demanding. While veryone is entitled to their opinion it has been found that intermediate algebra skills are increasingly becoming necessary in our rapidly changing world.

        The CCSSM (common core state standards in Mathematics) requires all students aster the mathematics through the level of intermediate algebra. You seem to contradict yourself when you state “Having a larger pool of well-qualified graduates would benefit employers in the technology sector”yet argue or lower graduation standards. Requiring Community College students to master intermediate algebra is a way of increasing problem-solving skills that employers value. But more important,it gives students the fou dation necessary for success in a college-level course.

        Are you seriously suggesting that there be no math requirement for a 4 year degree?

Template last modified: